A butler showing his pants pocket is empty

Lost/Stolen Cards

Debit Cards

If you've lost your First Harrison Debit Mastercard® and/or feel like it's been stolen, you'll want to take action as quickly as possible. We have several options for you to take care of any potential issues.

CardValet

Be sure you have the CardValet app. It is a standalone app that is separate from Banking Butler®. From the CardValet app, you can disable your debit card with the flick of a switch. Once you do so, you have the opportunity to look for your lost card while no one else can use it.

Apple App Store Badge  Google Play Store Badge  

Call Us

To report a lost or stolen First Harrison Personal Debit Card, call:

  • 812-364-6192 or 800-422-6192 during banking hours.
  • 800-472-3272 outside of banking hours.

When you call us, we can mail you a new debit card, or you can choose to stop by one of our locations, and we can print you an Instant Issue Debit Card.

Visit Us

Stop by one of our locations and let us know what’s happened with your First Harrison Debit Mastercard. We’ll take care of the issue in a jiffy. You could even walk out of our locations with an Instant Issue Debit Card.

Credit Cards

If you need to report a lost/stolen credit card, please call 1-800-367-7576. Our partner bank, TIB, will be able to help with stopping your existing card and getting a new one to you in the mail quickly.












A woman paying for a purchase with her phone

Mobile Wallet

When you have a First Harrison Debit Mastercard® or credit card, you can use your card in mobile wallets. It's safer and more convenient than using your physical card. Keep that card in your wallet and tap to make that purchase!

Mobile Wallet